Grade the Roster

[Tupin]

3.75.

No Geno, Animal Crosser, Krystal, Ridley, Ray 01, Bomberman, Bowser Jr., or Roy.

Plus the inclusion of [spoiler]ROB[/spoiler] brought the score down.

[Ultrasuperstarenator]

3.50

Kinda just okay,

[Lotos]

I might have graded too harshly. Yay complaints.  I voted 2 because:

• Certain FS's should have been more original
• I disliked how they took out some clones, yet added some semi clones that made Luigi look like a non-clone (Toon Link and Wolf are the main examples for the above two, I will forgive Ike because he was announced so we were expecting another clone/semi-clone).
• Having PT and Olimar as defaults isn't that great of an idea; as Java mentioned in a previous thread, it would be better to unlock them.
• Ness and Marth should be default instead of Ike and Lucas.  Those two are newcomers, they should be unlockable
• Come to think of it, too many newcomers are default.
• It could have used at least one more third party character.  Sonic and Snake weren't enough, but still, it's better than one/nothing.
• Very wanted/logical candidates such as Geno, Krystal (who would have been better than Wolf, even without a unique moveset), Bowser Jr/Shadow Mario, Animal Crossser, and Ridley were left out (at least Ridley made it in as a boss though).
• We could have had more playables, I mean, this IS online after all.

By the way, those were opinions, not facts, for people who were going to accuse me of that.

[Jono2]

3.00.  it could have been so much better.  so much.

[Avion-Finch]

solid four, it could been a teensey bit bigger, but what we got is pretty satisfying, all of my faves from melee are back. :)