I'm jumping on the roster bandwagon...

[Zora Link]

This is my first, so please be nice. :)

Mario
~~~~~~~~
Mario
Peach
Bowser
Wario
Luigi
Geno
Bowser jr. / Shadow Mario
Classic/8-bit Mario

Zelda
~~~~~~~~
Link
Zelda/Sheik
Ganondorf
WW Link
Midna (wolf link optional)

DK
~~~~~~~~
DK
Diddy

Yoshi
~~~~~~~~
Yoshi

Kirby
~~~~~~~~
Kirby
Metaknight
King Dedede

Fox
~~~~~~~~
Fox
Falco
Krystal

Pikmin
~~~~~~~~
Pikmin & Olimar

Metroid
~~~~~~~~
Samus
ZSS (as seperate, yes, it's still possible)

Classic/Retro
~~~~~~~~
G&W
Ice Climbers
Pit
Pac-Man

Animal Crossing
~~~~~~~~
Animal Crosser
Tom Nook (don't give me crap about the background thing)

Pokemon
~~~~~~~~
Pikachu
Pokemon Trainer
Jigglypuff
Lucario

F-Zero
~~~~~~~~
Captain Falcon

Mother
~~~~~~~~
Lucas
Ness

Fire Emblem
~~~~~~~~
Ike
Marth
Roy

Third party
~~~~~~~
Sonic
Snake

[Apollo]

i still am 100% sure geno wont get in(sorry Geno)
and i have said it a million times but if pixel mario gets in it should be called Jumpman.

[Ridley]

You put classic mario in before Ridley... :|

[tollhouse2006]

You forgot to put Wolf and Ridley in. 

[Triforceman22]

Midna...that's good...

But why classic Mario?

And where's ridley and Wolf?

[Apollo]

Midna...that's good...

But why classic Mario?

And where's ridley and Wolf?

Jumpman would be really cool but I cant imagine him having many moves.

[Triforceman22]

Midna...that's good...

But why classic Mario?

And where's ridley and Wolf?

Jumpman would be really cool but I cant imagine him having many moves.

just jumping and using a hammer....

[Zora Link]

no mistakes were made on this roster. that includes Classic mario, ridley and wolf. ;)
We all have our opinions.

[Apollo]

Midna...that's good...

But why classic Mario?

And where's ridley and Wolf?

Jumpman would be really cool but I cant imagine him having many moves.

just jumping and using a hammer....

yeah thats all i can think of too
maybe they will add in paper mario instead

WOW whatever happened to people wanting him?

[Hero_Of_Time]

Midna...that's good...

But why classic Mario?

And where's ridley and Wolf?

Jumpman would be really cool but I cant imagine him having many moves.

just jumping and using a hammer....

yeah thats all i can think of too
maybe they will add in paper mario instead

WOW whatever happened to people wanting him?

Paper Mario > Geno > Bowser Jr.

in terms of who would be better in Brawl imo