My roster Re-done.

[Water ☮]

Midna and Roy I don't see making it, but no animal crosser?! :O

[Java]

You didn't add any new franchises...

Also, I fail to see how Zelda will have more reps than Mario, while Mario doesn't gain any newcomers...

I'm gonna make a roster one of these days. 8)

umm... bowser jr.?

I mean from Melee to Brawl.
Mario loses Doc and gains Bowser Jr, resulting in no gain.

I'm pretty sure Sakurai considers Geno 1st party, so he's my guess for 6th Mario Rep.

no, sakurai considers Geno as third party. ;)
Besides, doc was a clone...

You are both so wrong.

SECOND PARTY! As in, Geno has shared rights for two different companies.

I know he's second party, but I was saying what SAKURAI considers him as.

[Triforceman22]

Midna and Roy I don't see making it, but no animal crosser?! :O

oops, forgot to put him in... I was really tired when I made this...
also Midna and roy have a pretty good chance.
well at least Midna does....

:P

[Water ☮]

Midna and Roy I don't see making it, but no animal crosser?! :O

oops, forgot to put him in... I was really tired when I made this...
also Midna and roy have a pretty good chance.
well at least Midna does....

:P

I think even Roy has a higher chance. besides them i like this roster because Krystal is in:)

[Zora Link]

Midna is on there: auto 10. :P
jk
Although I see you added her, which is always a plus.
I'm not flaming, but I just don't see seigfried in...sorry. :P

9/10

[Tupin]

Pretty good.

I think I'll  make a roster.

[Apollo]

not flaming your choice of midna but i think vaati has a better chance

[Zora Link]

not flaming your choice of midna but i think vaati has a better chance

:O
BANBANBANBANBANBAN!!!!
jk
Vaati is just known by less people...heck, I didn't even know who Vaati was until 5 months ago.

[Apollo]

not flaming your choice of midna but i think vaati has a better chance

:O
BANBANBANBANBANBAN!!!!
jk
Vaati is just known by less people...heck, I didn't even know who Vaati was until 5 months ago.

midna might be better known but thats only because of the success of twilight. True Zelda fans would agree Vaati is a better choice because he has played an important role in several Zelda games.

[QingXin]

Hello. this is my re-done most wanted characters.

Don't flame, don't spam, also this is my opinion, so don't score low, if you don't see your most wanted char. in here, K?
Good. :)

Mario series
***************
-Mario
-Luigi
-Peach
-Bowser
-Bowser jr.

Zelda series
***************
-Link
-Zelda
-Shiek (comes with zelda)
-ganondorf
-Young Link
-Midna

Yoshi series:
**************
-Yoshi

Donkey kong series
***************
-DK
-diddy
- k. Rool

Pikmin series
***************
-Olimar with pikmin

Star Fox series
**************
Fox
Krystal
Falco
wolf

F-zero series
**************
-Captain falcon
- Black Shadow

Metroid series
*************
-Samus (ZSS)
-Ridley

Fire emblem series
**************
Ike
Marth
Roy (Don't flame)
Black Knight

Pokemon series
*************
Pikachu
PKMN trainer
Jiggly puff
Mewtwo
Lucario

Kirby series
***********
Kirby
Dedede
Meta knight

Wario series:
***********
Wario

Mother series
**********
Lucas
Ness
Claus

Animal crossing series
***************
Animal Crosser

Classic
*********
Ice climbers
Pit
Game and watch

3rd-party
********
Snake
Sonic
Siegfried (also don't flame)
Geno

[Triforceman22]

Hello. this is my re-done most wanted characters.

Don't flame, don't spam, also this is my opinion, so don't score low, if you don't see your most wanted char. in here, K?
Good. :)

Mario series
***************
-Mario
-Luigi
-Peach
-Bowser
-Bowser jr.

Zelda series
***************
-Link
-Zelda
-Shiek (comes with zelda)
-ganondorf
-Young Link
-Midna

Yoshi series:
**************
-Yoshi

Donkey kong series
***************
-DK
-diddy
- k. Rool

Pikmin series
***************
-Olimar with pikmin

Star Fox series
**************
Fox
Krystal
Falco
wolf

F-zero series
**************
-Captain falcon
- Black Shadow

Metroid series
*************
-Samus (ZSS)
-Ridley

Fire emblem series
**************
Ike
Marth
Roy (Don't flame)
Black Knight

Pokemon series
*************
Pikachu
PKMN trainer
Jiggly puff
Mewtwo
Lucario

Kirby series
***********
Kirby
Dedede
Meta knight

Wario series:
***********
Wario

Mother series
**********
Lucas
Ness
Claus

Animal crossing series
***************
Animal Crosser

Classic
*********
Ice climbers
Pit
Game and watch

3rd-party
********
Snake
Sonic
Siegfried (also don't flame)
Geno

Siegfried is like my dream char.

Like Eggplant wizard is to cornwad
and like Classic mario is to Shujinco...
Hector to HTA...:P

[tollhouse2006]

Okay is good except for a few things

- Midna?
1. How would she fight? She never fights in TP
2. As a Zelda fan myself I know that you could find better characters, Midna has only appeared in 1 game, why not put in Navi while your at it?
3. Vaati is more important to the series.

- Lack of Wario and F-Zero Characters
For Wario you could add Ashley, Jimmy T., Kat & Ana etc...
F-Zero you could add Samurai Goroh, Black Shadow, etc...

- Kid Icarus should have it's own series
Pit could be accompanied by Eggplant Wizard  :|
And you do realise that most of these franchises are Old School right?

And that's it  :P

1. her magic hair can do the fighting for her...
2. Navi just tells you about the enemy not actual inflict pain upon them
3.Sakurai is focusing more on TP.

also this MY opinion.
also, didn't I say no flaming which means no ":|"
;)

Judging from the bolded sentence you obviously never played TP or you ignored the cut-scenes.  And if she's in TP she has a good chance since Sakurai's getting all the Zelda reps from there.  WW Link could get in though but MIdna's chances are good.

[Triforceman22]

Okay is good except for a few things

- Midna?
1. How would she fight? She never fights in TP
2. As a Zelda fan myself I know that you could find better characters, Midna has only appeared in 1 game, why not put in Navi while your at it?
3. Vaati is more important to the series.

- Lack of Wario and F-Zero Characters
For Wario you could add Ashley, Jimmy T., Kat & Ana etc...
F-Zero you could add Samurai Goroh, Black Shadow, etc...

- Kid Icarus should have it's own series
Pit could be accompanied by Eggplant Wizard  :|
And you do realise that most of these franchises are Old School right?

And that's it  :P

1. her magic hair can do the fighting for her...
2. Navi just tells you about the enemy not actual inflict pain upon them
3.Sakurai is focusing more on TP.

also this MY opinion.
also, didn't I say no flaming which means no ":|"
;)

Judging from the bolded sentence you obviously never played TP or you ignored the cut-scenes.  And if she's in TP she has a good chance since Sakurai's getting all the Zelda reps from there.  WW Link could get in though but MIdna's chances are good.

aparrentley Grim hasn't played it...
one of the best Wii games out there....
But that'll all change in 29 days.:P

[GrimTuesday]

I readded my thoughts.

I added my thoughts.

Okay is good except for a few things

- Midna?
1. How would she fight? She never fights in TP
That's a horrible excuse and I absolutely hate it. Just look at Captain Falcon and Fox...
I didn't say she couldn't fight I said how could she fight, as a question.
2. As a Zelda fan myself I know that you could find better characters, Midna has only appeared in 1 game, why not put in Navi while your at it?
Because Navi would make no sense at all... At least Midna has arms and legs. About the 1 appearance thing, Ice Climbers would like to say hi.
Hi Ice Climbers, they got in because they were from one of Sakurai's favourite games, I've never heard him say anything about TP being one of his favourites.
3. Vaati is more important to the series.
That may be true and in that case, so is Tingle.
I wouldn't be surprised to see Midna in Brawl though, seeing as how Sakurai is focusing on TP more.
No comment.
- Lack of Wario and F-Zero Characters
For Wario you could add Ashley, Jimmy T., Kat & Ana etc...
Wario does not need anymore characters...
All other characters are pretty much insignificant and there are much more worthier Nintendo characters than those.
Fair enough but I still think Wario is lonely.
F-Zero you could add Samurai Goroh, Black Shadow, etc...
O_O...Samurai Goroh has been confirmed an AT for quite some time now...
Black Shadow should be added though
This isn't the Brawl roster this is YOUR roster, and Sakurai made a mistake when he put Goroh as an AT, other than BS there is no other worthy F-Zero rep.
- Kid Icarus should have it's own series
Pit could be accompanied by Eggplant Wizard  :|
Kid Icarus doesn't need more than one rep...
It wasn't so important...
Same as Wario.
And you do realise that most of these franchises are Old School right?
There's only 3 old school franchises...
um... you should check release dates
Mario - 1981
Link - 1987
Kirby - 1992
and...
Ice Climbers - 1985
Pit - 1987
Game & Watch - 1980

see what I mean?

And that's it  :P

Also you can't ask someone not to flame you, if you have an opinion and share it with us other people are allowed to share their opinions as well.

[Java]

I readded my thoughts.

I added my thoughts.

Okay is good except for a few things

- Midna?
1. How would she fight? She never fights in TP
That's a horrible excuse and I absolutely hate it. Just look at Captain Falcon and Fox...
I didn't say she couldn't fight I said how could she fight, as a question.
She could use magic. I haven't gotten very far in TP, but as far as I know she could do some magic thing that formed a ring and allowed Wolf Link to charge or something

2. As a Zelda fan myself I know that you could find better characters, Midna has only appeared in 1 game, why not put in Navi while your at it?
Because Navi would make no sense at all... At least Midna has arms and legs. About the 1 appearance thing, Ice Climbers would like to say hi.
Hi Ice Climbers, they got in because they were from one of Sakurai's favourite games, I've never heard him say anything about TP being one of his favourites.
Sakurai's bias still doesn't change the fact that they only had 1 appearance though...

3. Vaati is more important to the series.
That may be true and in that case, so is Tingle.
I wouldn't be surprised to see Midna in Brawl though, seeing as how Sakurai is focusing on TP more.
No comment.

- Lack of Wario and F-Zero Characters
For Wario you could add Ashley, Jimmy T., Kat & Ana etc...
Wario does not need anymore characters...
All other characters are pretty much insignificant and there are much more worthier Nintendo characters than those.
Fair enough but I still think Wario is lonely.

-F-Zero you could add Samurai Goroh, Black Shadow, etc...
O_O...Samurai Goroh has been confirmed an AT for quite some time now...
Black Shadow should be added though
This isn't the Brawl roster this is YOUR roster, and Sakurai made a mistake when he put Goroh as an AT, other than BS there is no other worthy F-Zero rep.
This isn't my roster. :P This is Triforceman's roster and I'm fairly sure this was his Brawl roster not his Dream Roster and yes if he wasn't an AT he would have been a logical choice for a character.

- Kid Icarus should have it's own series
Pit could be accompanied by Eggplant Wizard  :|
Kid Icarus doesn't need more than one rep...
It wasn't so important...
Same as Wario.

-And you do realise that most of these franchises are Old School right?
There's only 3 old school franchises...
um... you should check release dates
Mario - 1981
Link - 1987
Kirby - 1992
and...
Ice Climbers - 1985
Pit - 1987
Game & Watch - 1980
Apparently my definition for old school franchises is different from yours. I consider an old school or "retro" franchise to be one that was made a while ago and is discontinued, meaning I don't consider Mario an old school franchise because he still has games.

see what I mean?

And that's it  :P

Also you can't ask someone not to flame you, if you have an opinion and share it with us other people are allowed to share their opinions as well.