Hmm. 9.5 from IGN?

[Kitchensink 3]

That's what Halo 3 got. Yet, Smash Melee got a 9.6. Melee< Halo 3. Brawl>Melee, so Brawl< Halo 3. That's algebra.

[Tuppyluver]

How about waiting until you play the game until you judge?

[ResidentZoidberg]

How about waiting until you play the game until you judge?

That^

And reviews don't work like that. The guy who reviewed MP3, he gave it a worse score then the first, yet he said 3 is MUCH better then the 1st. Reviews don't work like that.

[ME86]

I tend not to look at IGN's overall scores.... Mostly because it confuses the hell out of me.  :-[ I like to look at the individual scores. 

[FULL_METAL_RYDER2]

Not only were they rated in different eras, They were also rated by different people.
to compare there scores is fairly pointless.

[Tomboh]

Melee< Halo 3. Brawl<Melee

???

1 < 2 [RANDOM NUMBER THAT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH SUBJECT HERE] < 1

[TLO_FUZZBALL]

Halo>Melee. Melee>Brawl? I don't think so. Halo>Brawl? Maybe. Different types of games. Different systems. Not really comparable. ;)

That's common sense. Not Algebra.

[Cecil_and_Kain]

Metroid Prime > Halo 3

Metroid Prime 3 = Halo 3

Do the math.

[THELASTONESTANDING]

Halo>Melee. Melee>Brawl? I don't think so. Halo>Brawl? Maybe. Different types of games. Different systems. Not really comparable. ;)

That's common sense. Not Algebra.

Algebra fails. =P

[bluej33]

Associative property, baby! :D

Anyway, I'm not surprised by the 9.5. I've played it, and it's a lot of fun, but it's not really any better than Halo 2, at least in my opinion.

[TLO_FUZZBALL]

Halo>Melee. Melee>Brawl? I don't think so. Halo>Brawl? Maybe. Different types of games. Different systems. Not really comparable. ;)

That's common sense. Not Algebra.

Algebra fails. =P

Yeah it does.

[Sety]

Idiot.

You said that SSBM got a higher score then Halo 3, then said it was worse.

[Joe Kid]

That math doesn't really add up well.