Most overrated game ever?

[Gwen Khan]

Overall, Halo 3, shortly followed by the Orange Box and FFVII.

On a Nintendo system, probably Twilight Princess.

thank you, at last someone who agrees with me

Meh, it deserves most of the praise it gets.

I got really sick of all the "cake is a lie" crap, it made me pretty much have the game

[Syncopathic]

Also, Super Metroid. I just don't see how it's such a good game.  :O *prepares for flames*

It is indeed a bit overrated, but it's still pretty dang awesome. But then, only people who liked that kind of game in the first place would really appreciate it.

Ya. I'm a Metroid fan, but didn't really like the whole Don't Know Where Your Going thing. That's why Metroid fusion was my favorite out of the 2D ones. :)

...but there's only one possible path to take most of the time. Do you not have any sense of direction or something?

Well it's not like I can't find my way around, I just don't like it as much in the Metroid games.
But ya, Fusion pretty much tells you where to go every single time. :P

That's the reason why I don't like Fusion as much as Super Metroid.
I hated how it told you where to go, that takes away some of the challenge super metroid has. I would have liked it more than Super if it didn't tell you where to go.