Poll
Question:
Yeah, I'm late.
Option 1:
By Chloroform?
votes: 6
Option 2:
By Mackormoses
votes: 2
Option 3:
By captainjacksparrow
votes: 6
I am very late due to camping and me thinking I had 99 posts. Because of this I'm just gonna give people the whole week to vote.
voted DC.
CJS's looks awesome!
From my PoV...all 3 sucked.
Yes. Mine was blended way too much, chloro's has too much blur to the point that it counteracts, and cjs' is a background, render, and effect...aka 2 minute sig.
All three have their up and downs, each are noticeable. Mack's and Chloroform's signature are both monotone... also seem very simple. Captain's is also simple, but seems to have the best effects and flow that fit the render(Choice of comic). Mack's signature alone has a very unclear focal. There two texts(one simple and one not so simple) and two sets of eyes(Each different color). Overall not that appealing to me. Chloroform's signature is the most simple of the three, but fits the theme of the contest the most.
I vote for Captain on this.
Quote from: mackormoses on August 05, 2008, 03:39:42 PM
cjs' is a background, render, and effect...aka 2 minute sig.
Time doesn't matter. Take the Sistine Chapel ceiling painted by Michelangelo for instance... it was painted in just a little over 4 years. Someone could do the same in 3 years and it would look just a beautiful(Metaphorically speaking).
........... i vote for iron man. Also i agree with mack compared to last week these suck.
There's something with Chloroform's that I really like.
Quote from: MasterYoungLink on August 06, 2008, 07:12:43 PM
Quote from: captainjacksparrow on August 06, 2008, 08:17:21 AM
i vote for iron man.
Is that even valid?
The contest itself isn't organized that well, so the rules are very lax it would seem... even in Dill's "About Sig of the Week" thread though they are quite self-explanatory. So being that fact Chloroform? didn't make rules on voting, I would say it perfectly fine, though I am not one to call it right or wrong seeing I am not in charge of the contest.
I thought it would've been kind of a given that you shouldn't vote for yourself. I may add things to the rules thread that Dill missed, just to be clear for next time.
To even the stakes I suggest that myself and Mack vote for ourselves too.
And i quote from dill's sig of the week thread "You may vote for your own sig".
I don't like voting for myself, so I'll keep mine as Batman.
AND ITS A TIE!!!!
Quote from: mackormoses on August 05, 2008, 03:39:42 PM
Yes. Mine was blended way too much, chloro's has too much blur to the point that it counteracts, and cjs' is a background, render, and effect...aka 2 minute sig.
For those who aren't much into sig making. 2 minutes is way short. Most of mine now take around 1 hour to make ;-;.
I was too late to vote, but I pick Jack Sparrow's because of the good flow.
Mine usually take 20 minutes. If I take longer it's only because I'm stuck, otherwise I'll lose interest and proclaim it as a bad sig and move on. I usually only make sigs when I get a jolt of inspiration, causing me to know exactly what to do.