Should Shadow be playable?

[DededeCloneChris]

Are you Sonic fans not satisfied that atleast Sonic is in?!!!! >:(  Why do you want more Sonic characters?  You already got the blue hedgehog who doesn't wear pants!!  :D

But we need Amy or Cream, because they ARE in clothes!

[Java]

I voted Hell No!

For one thing, Tails and Eggman are both much more deserving. But we don't need any more Sonic reps.

It should be one 3rd-Party rep per company.

I see 4 Sonic AT's (if possible):
Tails
Eggman
Shadow
Knuckles

[Shujinco2]

What on Earth can Tails possibly do?  I've always pictured him as a wus but if you can tell how he can fight maybe I'll change my thoughts about him.  I know he can fly but what else can he do?

Well, he WAS the smart one!

Something with LOT'S of gadgets!

[Allegretto]

Shadow Should be playable Period.!

[Ridley]

Why do people like this thread so much? It just gets bumped every few hours.

[tollhouse2006]

Are you Sonic fans not satisfied that atleast Sonic is in?!!!! >:(  Why do you want more Sonic characters?  You already got the blue hedgehog who doesn't wear pants!!  :D

But we need Amy or Cream, because they ARE in clothes!

Would they seriously make it Brawl?   >:( I dought it.  Before they think about more third parties they should consider what NINTENDO characters deserve to be in because this is a NINTENDO game.  This isn't Sonic Battle or whatever it's called, it's Nintendo's Fighter.  I thought the third parties would stop after Sonic got in but I was wrong.  I don't think I can take any of this!!!   :'( 

[Skilliam]

Hell No lol  ::)