Who is the worst Newcomer?

[Shujinco2]

Do you mean as a character in the game, or as a character?

I don't really have an opinion for a character, but in game definitely Ike.

YAY! ANOTHER IKE HATER! :)

In the great words of Gimpy Fish:

"GARBAGE TIER"

:D

So, he's the mewtwo of Brawl?

[Rius]

I wouldn't know since I haven't played it yet, and I don't believe in going by hearsay.

[Apollo]

im gonna say that lucas is the worst. ness never really was that good either.

[Cornwad]

Zero Suit Samus really doesn't need to be there. I don't mind her as long as she doesn't take the place of another Metroid rep, however.

[DededeCloneChris]

Sonic. His fans annoy me greatly at times. And Lucas owns. Even through he might have replaced Ness.

I agree with the commander.

[fredrickthethird]

ZSS. Ike second choice

[DededeCloneChris]

Have you thinked what could happen if instead of Sonic fans.........were Dora the explorer fans?

[Jono2]

ZSS.  A completely worthless addition.  Ridley has a much larger role in the series than ZSS, and ZSS is a main character. :|

ZSS appears in many of the games, but is only playable in one of them (well, in Metroid as well, but that doesn't really count as it's not part of the main game).  ZSS was only put in for fanservice. :|

[Tupin]

Pokemon Trainer.

Utterly pointless.

[Triforceman22]

Lucas, PKM trainer...

So what if ike is garbage tier?
He can K.O people at freaking 30% damage!!!
ike is a great addition...

Lucas is pointless....
ness may be out because of him...  :robotindifferent:
ZSS is pretty pointless too.

[GrimTuesday]

Sonic, Snake (third parties shouldn't be in smash)

And Sonic's new game suck.

If you'd played Mother 3 you wouldn't say Lucas sucks, he rocks

Ike, GARBAGE TEIR!

[tollhouse2006]

I'd rather the 3rd parties not be in. 

[Shujinco2]

Sonic, Snake (third parties shouldn't be in smash)

And Sonic's new game suck.

If you'd played Mother 3 you wouldn't say Lucas sucks, he rocks

Ike, GARBAGE TEIR!

SO?

A good game doesn't make a good character! ;)

BUT, Ike IS very bad!

[Qsmash]

Also, I don't count ZSS as a newcomer because you can't choose her separatly.

[tollhouse2006]

Also, I don't count ZSS as a newcomer because you can't choose her separatly.

Well, she does have her own moveset and final smash so what do you count her as?