Would you like to see either Midna or Linebeck in another Zelda title, or, would you like to see them get axed from the series?
I just want Midna to return.
Please axe Midna, she wasn't in anyway as likeable as Navi or the King of Red Lions.
Linebeck, however, I wouldn't mind seeing in another game.
Quote from: mackormoses on May 29, 2008, 12:24:12 PM
Would you like to see either Midna or Linebeck in another Zelda title, or, would you like to see them get axed from the series?
I don't think Midna should return. There's no possible way for her to come back.
Linebeck...there's a chance he'll come back, only if there's a sequel to Phantom Hourglass. But I don't think there will be a sequel to Phantom Hourglass.
Also, this is curious indeed. You? Posting in Zelda? :O
I own a lot of Zelda titles, I just don't find them interesting enough to discuss regularly :O
I do think Linebeck could return, moreso than Midna, but I wouldn't count her out.
Although i love Midna's character, and think it would be sweet if she where in another game, i just don't see any way for them to pull it off. I mean,[spoiler]with her leaving and breaking the Twilight Mirror and all, how can she come back, or anyone from the Twilight realm for that matter? So as awesome as that is, it just can't work properly.
[/spoiler]
As for Linebeck, i would really like to see him in a future game as well. I mean, at least it is possible with him (and his character was just plain awesome :))
no, I want a Zelda game with no one helping you, where it's just Link on his own.
Quote from: Commissar Torgo on May 29, 2008, 03:41:31 PM
no, I want a Zelda game with no one helping you, where it's just Link on his own.
I don't want a remake of Adventure of Link anymore.
Yes for both. But Midna wouldn't be following you, just a character you see every now and again while playing, she wouldn't be in her Imp form either. And Linebeck could also come back, but not travel with you and stay in a city or something.
There are loopholes for Midna, ya know.
Quote from: mackormoses on May 29, 2008, 04:06:31 PM
There are loopholes for Midna, ya know.
true, but they would be purely deus ex machina
Linebeck overthrew the boat version of the King of red lions for my favorite zelda character! Of course! But what he did at the end of PH makes it seem like he's gone... :(
That's a toughy. I say that Linebeck should return, but have an even greater role than sailing you around and the occasional semi-major integration into the story, such as:
[spoiler]His crazy ex girlfriend[/spoiler]
or
[spoiler]Getting turned into a baddie.[/spoiler]
Quote from: MasterYoungLink on May 29, 2008, 03:45:01 PM
Quote from: Commissar Torgo on May 29, 2008, 03:41:31 PM
no, I want a Zelda game with no one helping you, where it's just Link on his own.
I don't want a remake of Adventure of Link anymore.
lol! I still haven't beat that game! :D
I'd like Linebeck to return, but Midna not so much. The only way I can see her returning I'd if Link searches for another way into a Twilight Realm to find her, like what happened at the beginning of MM. Linebeck was awesome and I'd love to see him return, but it probably won't happen.
I hate Linebeck for replacing King of Red Lions as Toon Link's boat person, so I don't want him to come back. I don't want Midna to come back either, but I would like the Twili, her race, to make an appearance as a more important group, like the Gorons and Zora's.
Honestly, I think they shouldn't repeat these characters in the games. The story suffers as it is from lack of originality, at least give us some different characters.
TAKE OUT MIDNA.
But Linebeck, he can stay.
I thought Linebeck was a great character, but I don't want to see anyone come back again. Comebacks usually = sequels, and I'm ready for a new chapter in the Zelda series. I imagine there will be some kind of Twilight Princess sequel, probably on a handheld, so Midna's got a greater chance of coming back. But I don't think she should.
nope, never want to see 'em again
I like Midna more than Linebeck, it would be nice to see her again. Linebeck is ok, not my favorite character (I prefer his crazy ex girlfriend :P)
Oh, is someone bumping old threads again? Enjoy your month ban.