Expert Notecharts

[PsychoYoshi]

OK, so we all know that Neversoft are (primarily) a bunch of idiots, and that most notecharts are closer to the actual song on Hard than they are on Expert. Still, there are a couple real gems that defy the norm like Cliffs.

Which songs do you think 'work' well on Expert, and which do you think were definitely better left to Harmonix to chart? For me...

Great:
-Cities on Flame with Rock and Roll
-Cliffs of Dover
-Cult of Personality (though the song still kicks my ass)
-Even Flow
-MNiJ
-Impulse

Terrible:
-Raining Blood (though it's terrible on all difficulties ^_^)
-Before I Forget
-3s and 7s
-Cherub Rock
-Same Old Song and Dance
-The Seeker
-Paint it Black
-Rock and Roll All Nite
-TTFAF

[sonicdude164]

I agree with your good list, but I don't think that Rock and Roll All Night is that bad, although Raining Blood, Before I Forget, 3's and 7's and Through the Fire and Flames are all pretty much horrible charts. I quote someone from scorehero: "It's like they charted BiF normally then played it on double notes, and decided they liked the chart better. So they kept it."