Main Menu

Should Link talk?

Started by shadowmarioguy, November 05, 2007, 03:33:02 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Do you think Link should actually talk in the next Zelda game?  (like with text bars and everything)

Yes
9 (16.1%)
No
47 (83.9%)

Total Members Voted: 54


zFan

Quote from: reborn07 on December 11, 2007, 09:13:04 AM
I think link should never talk it would ruin the game...(For me it would anyway.)
Yup.

THEBIRD

*Clicks 'No'*

Hm, I wonder why the four people who hit 'yes' aren't showing their faces in the crowd of 'No's.

Mystic

No.

The last time he had a voice ruined it for me, thanks.

Cecil_and_Kain

I'm not entirely sure, but at the end of Phantom Hourglass I think he says one line.

HYRULESEAS

 No, he shouldn't talk at all. It would just be to weird.


Ridley for Brawl!  hi i'm Toad! :)

zeldafreak008

Na, Link is meant to be a character that cannot talk.  Just as said before, Link is meant to be YOU, which is why you can change his name.  The series of grunts and all are fine.  A little bit of talking would be fine, but as long as he doesn't talk the whole time and utters phrases like "WELL EXCCCUUUUSSSS ME PRINCESS!"

[color="darkgreen"]CLICK MAH SIG FOR SOMETHING COOL![/color]

Java

Quote from: Mystic Swampert on December 23, 2007, 02:04:29 AM
No.

The last time he had a voice ruined it for me, thanks.
Excuuuuuuuuuuuuse Me Princess.

BOREDFOREVER

Quote from: Oren on December 14, 2007, 08:10:24 PM
no  i just think that would mess with the feel of it

So true.

Link has always rocked as the silent hero.  He's a lot more endearing/bad ass that way.   But i do like the way that the creators are going with his body language and expressions.  Right now he has no need to talk.

SkyMyl

Yes for text bar, NO FOR VOICEOVERS (Watch the Zelda Cartoon, play the Non-existent CD-i games and you'll know why.)!

But, the only problem: It would make Link less cool.

Ultrasuperstarenator

Quote from: MasterYoungLink on December 31, 2007, 03:13:26 PM
Yes for text bar, NO FOR VOICEOVERS (Watch the Zelda Cartoon, play the Non-existent CD-i games and you'll know why.)!

But, the only problem: It would make Link less cool.

Oh, come on! Stop saying this! these weren't made by Nintendo, so who CARES how bad they are, or that the even MATTER?

And maybe I got spoiled by metroid prime 3,  but last time i checked, voice acting is WAY better than Text. as long as it's good.

SkyMyl

Quote from: Ultrasuperstarenator on January 10, 2008, 11:21:19 AM
Quote from: MasterYoungLink on December 31, 2007, 03:13:26 PM
Yes for text bar, NO FOR VOICEOVERS (Watch the Zelda Cartoon, play the Non-existent CD-i games and you'll know why.)!

But, the only problem: It would make Link less cool.

Oh, come on! Stop saying this! these weren't made by Nintendo, so who CARES how bad they are, or that the even MATTER?

And maybe I got spoiled by metroid prime 3,  but last time i checked, voice acting is WAY better than Text. as long as it's good.
What wasn't made by Nintendo (sarcasm)?

Can I take my vote back? I said yes...but I want to change it back now.

Silverhawk79

No, I like giving Link his own voice in my head.

Helios

I'd have no objections to him talking, but it's not really necessary. Nintendo did an excellent job showing his emotions and what type of character Link was in Twilight Princess just by using facial expressions and body language. If they continue to do that well, words aren't really needed to give Link a personality.

Gomu

link should never ever talk ever, but i would like the npcs to talk