Deserving characters that didn't make it.

[Triforce_Luigi]

Goomba would make a better character than Geno.  Why would you want some crappy looking puppet.

Why would you want a plumber in a red hat? Or a blue hedgehog? Or a chimp who shoots peanuts. Or a pink puffball with a large appetite. I think you get my point.

Yeah, I get it, but I still think Geno makes a lame character.  He's no where close to being as popular as the names you mentioned.

Goomba would make a better character than Geno.  Why would you want some crappy looking puppet.

One of his attacks causes 9999 damage. :-X

Besides, he was like one of the most wanted in Japan.

Popularity from Japan is the reason why Pichu unfortunately got in melee.  Geno isn't even well known.

Yes, somehow, judging from the reaction, I don't think R.O.B. was a particularly popular character.

[Tupin]

Goomba would make a better character than Geno.  Why would you want some crappy looking puppet.

Why would you want a plumber in a red hat? Or a blue hedgehog? Or a chimp who shoots peanuts. Or a pink puffball with a large appetite. I think you get my point.

Yeah, I get it, but I still think Geno makes a lame character.  He's no where close to being as popular as the names you mentioned.

Goomba would make a better character than Geno.  Why would you want some crappy looking puppet.

One of his attacks causes 9999 damage. :-X

Besides, he was like one of the most wanted in Japan.

Popularity from Japan is the reason why Pichu unfortunately got in melee.  Geno isn't even well known.

Yes, somehow, judging from the reaction, I don't think R.O.B. was a particularly popular character.

And if Geno wasn't well known, why was he like the second most wanted Brawl newcomer?

In case you're wondering, Dedede was the first.

[tibar7]

if geno was really wanted in brawl every one would've known about him. the most wanted characters were Ike and Sonic

[zeldaguy6]

This guy too.

is that animal crosser?

Noob, its geno.

[Ares300]

Ridley, Zant, Wolf, and, if Akklaim was still around, Tal 'Set, or, as we know him better by, Turok.

[Michael227]

Ridley, Zant, Wolf, and, if Akklaim was still around, Tal 'Set, or, as we know him better by, Turok.

WOLF IS IN FOOL

[buttlord420]

I just thought of another one

Lyn from fire emblem....sure she is an assist trophy, but id rather see her as a playable charcter

[Rius]

Ridley, Zant, Wolf, and, if Akklaim was still around, Tal 'Set, or, as we know him better by, Turok.

WOLF IS IN FOOL

I lol'd. :D

Let's see, Mega Man, X, or Zero.
Animal Crosser
Ridley
King K. Rool
Uncloned clones. >:(
Kinda wanted Wind Waker Gannondorf more than Twilight Princess Gannondorf.
Mewtwo
Bomberman
0² as a boss.
Vaati
Midna/ Wolf Link
Sigurd

That's all at the moment.

[tibar7]

Goomba would make a better character than Geno.  Why would you want some crappy looking puppet.

Why would you want a plumber in a red hat? Or a blue hedgehog? Or a chimp who shoots peanuts. Or a pink puffball with a large appetite. I think you get my point.

Yeah, I get it, but I still think Geno makes a lame character.  He's no where close to being as popular as the names you mentioned.

Goomba would make a better character than Geno.  Why would you want some crappy looking puppet.

One of his attacks causes 9999 damage. :-X

Besides, he was like one of the most wanted in Japan.

Popularity from Japan is the reason why Pichu unfortunately got in melee.  Geno isn't even well known.

Yes, somehow, judging from the reaction, I don't think R.O.B. was a particularly popular character.

characters like krystal, ridley, ray 01, toad, and tom nook or animal crosser would've made much better playables than geno.

[Michael227]

Goomba would make a better character than Geno.  Why would you want some crappy looking puppet.

Why would you want a plumber in a red hat? Or a blue hedgehog? Or a chimp who shoots peanuts. Or a pink puffball with a large appetite. I think you get my point.

Yeah, I get it, but I still think Geno makes a lame character.  He's no where close to being as popular as the names you mentioned.

Goomba would make a better character than Geno.  Why would you want some crappy looking puppet.

One of his attacks causes 9999 damage. :-X

Besides, he was like one of the most wanted in Japan.

Popularity from Japan is the reason why Pichu unfortunately got in melee.  Geno isn't even well known.

Yes, somehow, judging from the reaction, I don't think R.O.B. was a particularly popular character.

characters like krystal, ridley, ray 01, toad, and tom nook or animal crosser would've made much better playables than geno.

[Ares300]

Ridley, Zant, Wolf, and, if Akklaim was still around, Tal 'Set, or, as we know him better by, Turok.

WOLF IS IN FOOL

Really? Last I checked he wasnt.

[Skye8600]

if geno was really wanted in brawl every one would've known about him. the most wanted characters were Ike and Sonic

Tibar, you didnt even know who Eggman was. your not very well informed.
i do have to say that Geno wouldve made a pretty good playable.

[Sync123]

the characters i wanted are:
sora- his final smash could have been his Final Form
roy-they should have brought him back but not as a marth clone
animal crosser-would have been an interesting character
mewtwo-i just think he's cool lol
black knight-brawl needs more villains
lloyd irving-i think he's cool too plus his final smash could have been his Falcon's Crest
kratos(tales of symphonia) again another cool character and final smash would be Shining Bind
geno-interesting character

[tibar7]

if geno was really wanted in brawl every one would've known about him. the most wanted characters were Ike and Sonic

Tibar, you didnt even know who Eggman was. your not very well informed.
i do have to say that Geno wouldve made a pretty good playable.

do u like geno better than krystal and ridley. eggman is that stupid villian from sonic. i always get mixed up with the eggplant wizard

[tibar7]

i wish roy and mewtwo made it back